We have noticed press reports recently noting global changes in the MSCI
(Morgan Stanley Capital International) indices. GICS (Global Industry
Classification Standards) run by the United States company Standard & Poors
are also considering a realignment of listed companies.
Those following the markets, will be interested to note fund managers
reactions to this. They believe that the Australian market will experience
a massive upheaval.
MSCI Free Float index refers to the amount of stock "freely traded" rather
than by market capitalisation. This has large implications for stocks such
as Telstra and Newscorp. If this proposal goes ahead, stocks are
categorised into 10 brackets according to the percentage of shares that are
freely available to investors. Shares that are not freely available are
classed in a number of ways, and this includes holdings by
Director's/Founder's or the Government. If this comes about, Telstra's
rating would be at 50% instead of the full 100% it has now. Mr Murdoch
would face a similar problem at Newscorp. Foreign ownership restrictions
are also accounted for.
MSCI may have affect on the following;
Large stocks at Risk from Potential Downgrades:
The US standards rate stocks with large holdings by founders differently
than we have in the past in Australia.
News Corp, Telstra, Cable and Wireless Optus, Coca-Cola Amatil, AXA Asia
Pacific, Wesfarmers, Computershare & Aristocrat
These are the companies where either govt and / or owner founders have
large holdings, ie the percentage of stock available to trade is less,
making the stock less liquid. Under the new ratings, these companies will
have less importance and weight in the index. hence global index fund
managers will have to shed some stock.
Note: News Corp, Telstra, Cable and Wireless Optus, are currently in a
downtrend
Coca-Cola Amatil, AXA Asia Pacific, Wesfarmers, Computershare & Aristocrat
are currently sideways or up.
Large Stocks with High Free Float:
If these stocks remain at full weight, they will increase in importance in
the country index.
National Bank, Commonwealth Bank, Westpac, ANZ, BHP, AMP and Brambles.
It is interesting to note that these charts are already either up or
sideways. One would expect this to continue into the date these changes
take effect.
Larger Stocks Possibly included in Indices:
Australian Stock Exchange, Lang Corporation, Macquarie Bank, Qantas, Sonic
Healthcare, Woodside, Westfield America, Westfield Holdings. All of these
stocks are up, except for Qantas, which is currently trending sideways.
(QAN announced a major capital outlay, expected to reduce earnings in the
near term).
This is classic Dow Theory in action. All the news, good or bad, has
already been factored into the price. The fund managers would have known
about the possibility of these changes months before the news was made
public and hence bought or sold shares to match the new weighting the stock
will hold in the index after the changes.
Attached are the charts of Newscorp, National Australia Bank & Australian
Stock Exchange. Notice how in all these charts, a change in trend or a
stronger continuation of the current trend, occurred roughly 2 months prior
(September) to news announcements in late November. Keep your eyes on these
developments and future announcements.
See also, AFR reporting, nov 20th in the market wrap section.